IdolsSA: Was it a mistake to have Thembi as a judge? Here’s what viewers said about her tonight

IdolsSA: Was it a mistake to have Thembi as a judge? Here’s what viewers said about her tonight

While you’re here, please follow me.


 

The Idols judging panel has been reshuffled and the emotions around this are mixed.

Some people have warned up to Thembi Seete and JR but others have their criticism as expected. One person who was put on public trial for her judging was Thembi Seete.

According to some viewers, Thembi is doing a lousy job as a judge. Her failure to offer what is deemed as lucrative and “substance” comments to contestants is the major reason why some have claimed that she’s flopping as a judge.

One comment read, “Why does it feel like Thembi compliments all contestants without actually taking the time to analyze their performances like a judge should, she agrees with everything! How are they supposed to grow & move to Top 3? Thank you JR and Somizi for analyzing #IdolsSA”

This was supported by Londie Mthethwa, who claimed that Thembi literally repeats whatever Somizi says, “One thing about sis thembi she will copy and paste everything Somizi says😭 #IdolsSA”

Other comments couldn’t help observing that her comments are hardly about the performance itself and focuses rather on looks or smiles. For her to be a judge but fail to criticize constructively is causing quite the stir on the socials. It brings the question about whether it was a mistake to take her on as a judge.

Here are the rest of the comments:

Thoughts?

Thank you for reading this. Please leave your comments in the comments section below and I’ll engage!

Source: IdolsSA on DStv channel 161

Source: https://twitter.com/Rowan_c_haai/status/1576602091208179713?t=GeEyL0gWSRFFkD4Yvom3uA&s=19

October 02, 2022.